MSSVision: The Place for Independent Music Videos
Search:

Critiques  Request a Song Critique
 
 
 

Artist name: Minster Hill; Song title: "Siberian Farmland"

Since 1997 Minster Hill in it's various line-ups and variation has been slowly releasing earth-challenging music.

Visit Artist' site for this and other songs: MinsterHill.com; Song Lyrics

 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |

 

Add Comment  
Name:
Country:
Link: http://
Comment:
  Read Comments  

Read Readers' Comments

Minster Hill
Minster Hill
Web site

More Minster Hill:

  More MSSVision  
 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Minster Hill -> Minster Hill

"Siberian Farmland" is a title ingeniously thought, it does what a title should do - says "remember me" and "aren't you interested to see what the songs is about"?

The intro is also exceptional! It really grabs you and says "listen to me and keep listening"!

And what about the constant and positive energy spread throughout the track? It is addictive! It asks you to become a part of the song. And you will. You will if you remember the 80s. But if you don't...?!

So let's revise what we've got so far:

an excellent song that reminds the 80s. Is that last thing a good or a bad one? I don't know. Maybe Tommy Mottola could find the answer relatively easy - he's got the potential. But I'm not going to wonder about that. Let's assume that the song is perfect for the 80's (it is, and let's not worry about), and that for this tune the 80s sound is not good enough. So, we need something different.

That different thing is the guitar part mainly. Again, like in other Minster Hill songs, the guitar part is very well thought and performed, but maybe not enough suitable for a modern sound. And again, it can be easily improved.

The first thing is to get rid of the funky guitar rhythm on Verse. Done? OK, now just let the guitar move along with the bass. Same part as before, but rhythmically like the bass. And since a contrast with the part on Chorus would be really helpful, play it muted. That is muted guitar and open chords at end of phrases during the Verse.

For a better contrast, on Chorus you should play just rhythmic plain full chords. Make it simple, natural, and powerful... Now you've got a winning song!

And by the way, you should change, in the same way as on Chorus, the rhythm guitar part on the solo too. Give it a try, it should work. Right now it seems to me that you loose some energy there.

I'd like to add also that the keyboard part and sound are really good here. The way they are now is a good combination that adds colors and beat to a song of any time. Good choice and use!

Once again I hear the Beatlesque choice of back vocals. This time I think their use helps the song. Maybe because they complement the song's feelings with their positive nuances. Or maybe because they make a good "team" with the harmony. Anyway, in my opinion the effect they produce will be even greater when you modify the guitar as described above.

Overall, the track shows a very skillful songwriting and professional performance. It has an enormous commercial potential and... here's a thought - it reminds me of some recent Hits from The Darkness. Not because of the vocals, or the instruments, or the style. Maybe the energy?! Take that in consideration too, and my compliments!

Good Luck,
Anton Tontchev
for MSSVision.com - Sep/10/04

 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |

 

Comments  

 


Subscribe:
Copyright 2001-2008 . MSSVision.com . e-mail
Site Map - Advertise - Register - Help - About - Privacy | Fans - Music Video Submissions - Archives - Music Industry Links

This site contains materials protected by International Copyright Laws.
Any unauthorized use is prohibited and will not be tolerated.