Home    

Independent Artists Song Critiques / reviews

Watch Live Watch Live Watch Live Watch Live Watch Live Watch Live
   
Live
Webcast
Music
Videos
Music &
Films
News &
Dates
New
Entries
Featured
Artist

Critiques  Request a Song Critique
 
 
 

Artist name: Victoria Boiko; Song title: "A Melody"

An emotional mix of powerful tender in voice and melody!
Visit Artist' site for this and other songs: Iuma/VictoriaBoiko; Play song from MSSVision;

 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |

 

Add Comment  
Name:
Country:
Link: http://
Comment:
  Read Comments  

Read Readers' Comments

Victoria Boiko
Victoria Boiko
Web site

 

  More MSSVision  
 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Victoria Boiko -> Victoria Boiko

Nice melody! ...More than nice!

It catches your feelings and takes you into an emotional state of sensuality.Same with the harmonies.

Both, melody/harmony and voice, have the tender power that'll make you remember the song and the performance.
Will make you remember that the singer and songwriter Victoria has something (that is) worth listening to say and express!

By the way, this is what being an Artist is all about.

I don't wanna say that this song is a "first class Art Work". But I can tell you what I feel about it - it's coming from the heart, Victoria writes and signs from the heart.

So, the song is well saturated with "hearts, feelings, emotions and tenderness"!
What is missing is a good Structure and a better arrangement.

Right now the Structure is something like this:
~"Section A", "Instrumental Part", "Section A";

It's not clear what the "Section A" really is. Actually it could be the Verse, or the Chorus, or the Bridge or any and all of them. There's too much stuff in it.

And the second part of it is screaming - "what about me?", "what I am supposed to do?", "...why?". And also - "why is the keyboard trying to take over me"... a few seconds...and...
...well, ...here is the synth ...it wins....:
There is the Instrumental part which is begging you: "take a breath and start over". And "Section A" starts over!

What the above shows is: too many feelings and not enough logic.
You are the song! What a song (or you) should communicate is feelings, emotions, ideas etc. ...but let me shout it here for everybody reading:
THE LISTENER CAN ACCEPT YOU ONLY AT WELL BALANCED DOSES! (and preferably with water or other soft or dry drinks) :)
You should put the parts that compose a song in a good order; and don't overdo! Keep it simple!

So, you could take the first 8 measures from "Section A" and use it as the Verse. It'll be quite enough and a quite good melodic Verse.
Then take the strongest words/phrase from the lyrics and use it for the Chorus. I believe you'll be able to write something even more melodically exciting! What you have is quite good but it needs a clear direction.

When the above is done, you'll have the most important parts of the song.

Now work a little more on the Arrangement. Start with choosing proper Instruments.
The Organ and Harp like synths are OK, but the one "voice like" is harming your song.
Think of adding something laying in the low register - it will contrast and underline the beautiful voice and melody in the high register.
An acoustic guitar playing rhythm could help your song further.
BTW, with those nice melodies and your clear voice, this song would sound very impressive when performed simply with a voice and piano.

So, we've got so far a very well performed song with a stylish and emotional melody. I'm sure the structure will be improved, if not here, in other tracks this talented singer/songwriter will offer to the World! Looking forward to listen more music from Victoria!

Good Luck,
Anton Tontchev
for MSSVision.com - 10/31/2002

 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |

 

Comments  

 


Facebook | Subscribe:
Copyright 2001-2011 . MSSVision.com . e-mail
Site Map - Advertise - Help - About - Privacy | Fans - Music Video Submissions - Music Industry Links . Terms, Conditions, & Privacy

This site contains materials protected by International Copyright Laws.
Any unauthorized use is prohibited and will not be tolerated.